This week's picks

Troy vs. James Madison Prediction and Pick, Week 9 2026

Big Al's CFB Lab
Data updated
Site
Picks two teams at random. Any FBS team can come up.

How we picked it

How we picked it

Three ratings look at a team in three different ways. The numbers' pick is the team at least two of them favor. On the toss-ups and the biggest games, Big Al makes the call himself and says why.

Where the game is won

Where the game is won

Each row puts one team's unit against the unit it faces, by national rank out of all FBS teams. An edge is a gap of 25 spots or more.

Ratings: SP+ via CFB Update; PRIME via primecfb.com. Box and play stats computed from CollegeFootballData.com play data (via the public cfbfastR files), FBS games only for scoring. Rushing yards here exclude sacks, so they run higher than official totals. Ranks are out of 138 FBS teams.

Share as an image

Image style

Leave a field empty to drop it from the image. A blank line in the description starts a new paragraph.

Troy at James Madison

Week 9, Thu, Oct 29, 7:30 PM ET, Bridgeforth Stadium.

Big Al's pick: James Madison, 93% to win.

The game

KickoffThu, Oct 29, 7:30 PM ET
TVESPN2
WhereBridgeforth Stadium
Weather60°, clear, wind 5 mph
LineJames Madison −21, total 49.5
Line movementOpened James Madison −17.5; moved 3.5 points toward James Madison. Total opened 52.5, down 3.
SeriesJames Madison leads 2–0
Last meetingJames Madison 31–14 in 2025

The ratings and the line

MarginWin chanceTotal
SP+James Madison by 23.395%50
PRIMEJames Madison by 15.587%
EloJames Madison96%
The lineJames Madison −21, opened −17.549.5, opened 52.5

Margins include home field. SP+ is Bill Connelly's rating; Sources has PRIME and Elo. Line and total from DraftKings, as of Wed, Oct 28, 2:21 PM ET.

Who wins, Troy or James Madison?

Big Al's pick: James Madison. 93% to win

Which matchups decide Troy vs. James Madison?

All three ratings favor James Madison, by 15.5 to 23.3 points, and it isn't close. James Madison's best matchup is its pass protection, 17th in sacks allowed per dropback, against Troy's pass rush at 118th. Troy's way back in is its 3rd down defense, 17th in 3rd downs allowed, against James Madison's 3rd down offense at 99th.

Troy with the ball

James Madison with the ball

Who's out for Troy and James Madison?

Troy

James Madison

How Troy and James Madison compare, in charts

Which team is better on offense and on defense?

Which team is better on offense and on defense? Troy lands in the struggling corner (below the FBS average on offense and on defense); James Madison in the complete teams corner (better than the FBS average on offense and on defense). James Madison is ahead on offense, 32.5 (33rd) to Troy's 19.1 (112th) in SP+ offense, and ahead on defense, 21.7 (37th) to Troy's 28.8 (91st) in SP+ defense.1020304010152025303540SP+ offense: better →SP+ defense: better →Defense firstComplete teamsStrugglingOffense first
Troy lands in the struggling corner (below the FBS average on offense and on defense); James Madison in the complete teams corner (better than the FBS average on offense and on defense). James Madison is ahead on offense, 32.5 (33rd) to Troy's 19.1 (112th) in SP+ offense, and ahead on defense, 21.7 (37th) to Troy's 28.8 (91st) in SP+ defense.
SP+ offenseSP+ defense
Troy19.1 (112th)28.8 (91st)
James Madison32.5 (33rd)21.7 (37th)

Who wins on early downs?

Who wins on early downs? Troy lands in the defense carries it corner (better than average on defense, below it on offense); James Madison in the good on both sides corner (better than the FBS average on offense and on defense). James Madison is ahead on offense, 57.1% (62nd) to Troy's 54.4% (83rd) in SUPLEX, and ahead on defense, 48.5% (31st) to Troy's 53.2% (63rd) in SUPLEX allowed.40%50%60%70%80%40%45%50%55%60%65%70%75%SUPLEX on offense: better →SUPLEX allowed on defense: better →Defense carries itGood on both sidesStrugglingOffense carries it
Troy lands in the defense carries it corner (better than average on defense, below it on offense); James Madison in the good on both sides corner (better than the FBS average on offense and on defense). James Madison is ahead on offense, 57.1% (62nd) to Troy's 54.4% (83rd) in SUPLEX, and ahead on defense, 48.5% (31st) to Troy's 53.2% (63rd) in SUPLEX allowed.
SUPLEXSUPLEX allowed
Troy54.4% (83rd)53.2% (63rd)
James Madison57.1% (62nd)48.5% (31st)

How do the two offenses move the ball?

How do the two offenses move the ball? Troy lands in the struggling corner (below the FBS average at staying on schedule and at hitting big plays); James Madison in the efficient and explosive corner (better than the FBS average at staying on schedule and at hitting big plays). James Madison is ahead at staying on schedule, 45.4% (51st) to Troy's 41.9% (87th) in success rate, and ahead at hitting big plays, 14.2% (28th) to Troy's 10.5% (111th) in explosive play rate.8%10%13%15%18%35%40%45%50%55%Success rate: stays on schedule more →Explosive play rate: more big plays →Boom or bustEfficient and explosiveStrugglingGrind it out
Troy lands in the struggling corner (below the FBS average at staying on schedule and at hitting big plays); James Madison in the efficient and explosive corner (better than the FBS average at staying on schedule and at hitting big plays). James Madison is ahead at staying on schedule, 45.4% (51st) to Troy's 41.9% (87th) in success rate, and ahead at hitting big plays, 14.2% (28th) to Troy's 10.5% (111th) in explosive play rate.
Success rateExplosive play rate
Troy41.9% (87th)10.5% (111th)
James Madison45.4% (51st)14.2% (28th)

Which defense is harder to move on?

Which defense is harder to move on? Both land in the lockdown defenses corner: better than the FBS average at keeping offenses behind schedule and at limiting big plays. James Madison is slightly better at keeping offenses behind schedule, 37.9% (40th) to Troy's 38.5% (48th) in success rate allowed. Troy is slightly better at limiting big plays, 10.2% (48th) to James Madison's 10.3% (52nd) in explosive plays allowed.5%10%15%20%30%35%40%45%50%55%Success rate allowed: fewer →Explosive plays allowed: fewer →Bend, don't breakLockdown defensesLeakyStingy but gives up big plays
Both land in the lockdown defenses corner: better than the FBS average at keeping offenses behind schedule and at limiting big plays. James Madison is slightly better at keeping offenses behind schedule, 37.9% (40th) to Troy's 38.5% (48th) in success rate allowed. Troy is slightly better at limiting big plays, 10.2% (48th) to James Madison's 10.3% (52nd) in explosive plays allowed.
Success rate allowedExplosive plays allowed
Troy38.5% (48th)10.2% (48th)
James Madison37.9% (40th)10.3% (52nd)

Who runs it and throws it better?

Who runs it and throws it better? Both land in the ground and pound corner: better than average running it, below it throwing it. James Madison is ahead running it, 5.8 (24th) to Troy's 5.5 (40th) in yards per carry, and ahead throwing it, 7.6 (68th) to Troy's 7.1 (87th) in yards per attempt.46810124567Yards per carry: better →Yards per pass attempt: better →Air it outBalanced and goodStuckGround and pound
Both land in the ground and pound corner: better than average running it, below it throwing it. James Madison is ahead running it, 5.89 (24th) to Troy's 5.53 (40th) in yards per carry, and ahead throwing it, 7.66 (68th) to Troy's 7.19 (87th) in yards per attempt.
Yards per carryYards per attempt
Troy5.53 (40th)7.19 (87th)
James Madison5.89 (24th)7.66 (68th)

Who wins on third down?

Who wins on third down? Both land in the gets off the field corner: better than average at getting off the field on third down, below it at converting third downs. Troy is ahead at converting third downs, 37.0% (89th) to James Madison's 35.6% (99th) in 3rd down conversion, and ahead at getting off the field on third down, 30.3% (17th) to James Madison's 36.4% (50th) in 3rd downs allowed.20%30%40%50%30%35%40%45%50%55%60%3rd down conversion, offense: better →3rd downs allowed, defense: better →Gets off the fieldWins third downLoses third downStays on the field
Both land in the gets off the field corner: better than average at getting off the field on third down, below it at converting third downs. Troy is ahead at converting third downs, 37.0% (89th) to James Madison's 35.6% (99th) in 3rd down conversion, and ahead at getting off the field on third down, 30.3% (17th) to James Madison's 36.4% (50th) in 3rd downs allowed.
3rd down conversion3rd downs allowed
Troy37.0% (89th)30.3% (17th)
James Madison35.6% (99th)36.4% (50th)

Each chart puts all 138 FBS teams on two stats; Troy and James Madison are lit. Dashed lines are the FBS averages, and up and right is better. Ranks in parentheses. Games through Oct 24, 2026.

How Troy's and James Madison's players compare

How do the quarterbacks compare?

How do the quarterbacks compare? Troy's Will Crowder is in the struggling corner, below average in both: 37.4% passing success rate (140th of 171 quarterbacks) and 1,174 passing yards (92nd). James Madison's Camden Coleman is in the struggling corner, below average in both: 45.2% passing success rate (55th of 171 quarterbacks) and 1,574 passing yards (48th). Coleman has the edge on both.35%40%45%50%55%60%65%1,0001,5002,0002,5003,000Efficient on low volumeVolume and efficiencyStrugglingVolume over efficiencyPassing yards →Passing success rate (per dropback) ↑ColemanCrowder
Troy's Will Crowder is in the struggling corner, below average in both: 37.4% passing success rate (140th of 171 quarterbacks) and 1,174 passing yards (92nd). James Madison's Camden Coleman is in the struggling corner, below average in both: 45.2% passing success rate (55th of 171 quarterbacks) and 1,574 passing yards (48th). Coleman has the edge on both.
PlayerPassing success rate (per dropback)Passing yards
Will Crowder, Troy37.4% (140th)1,174 (92nd)
Camden Coleman, James Madison45.2% (55th)1,574 (48th)

How do the lead running backs compare?

How do the lead running backs compare? Troy's Gavin Griffin is in the struggling corner, below average in both: 4.6 yards per carry (222nd of 360 running backs) and 40.2% rushing success rate (233rd). James Madison's George Pettaway is in the struggling corner, below average in both: 6.5 yards per carry (49th of 360 running backs) and 50.8% rushing success rate (59th). Pettaway has the edge on both.4681030%40%50%60%70%80%Boom or bustEfficient and explosiveStrugglingMoves the chainsRushing success rate →Yards per carry ↑PettawayGriffin
Troy's Gavin Griffin is in the struggling corner, below average in both: 4.6 yards per carry (222nd of 360 running backs) and 40.2% rushing success rate (233rd). James Madison's George Pettaway is in the struggling corner, below average in both: 6.5 yards per carry (49th of 360 running backs) and 50.8% rushing success rate (59th). Pettaway has the edge on both.
PlayerYards per carryRushing success rate
Gavin Griffin, Troy4.6 (222nd)40.2% (233rd)
George Pettaway, James Madison6.5 (49th)50.8% (59th)

How do the top receivers compare?

How do the top receivers compare? Troy's TK Keyes is in the role players corner, below average in both: 4 explosive catches (402nd of 669 receivers and tight ends) and 288 receiving yards (204th). Troy's Jace Petty is in the role players corner, below average in both: 3 explosive catches (496th of 669 receivers and tight ends) and 174 receiving yards (424th). James Madison's Makai Jackson is in the role players corner, below average in both: 12 explosive catches (44th of 669 receivers and tight ends) and 540 receiving yards (40th). James Madison's Corey Scott is in the role players corner, below average in both: 11 explosive catches (60th of 669 receivers and tight ends) and 371 receiving yards (122nd).051015202502004006008001,0001,200Big plays on low volumeGo-to deep threatsRole playersYards without the big playsReceiving yards →Explosive catches (16+ yards) ↑ScottJacksonPettyKeyes
Troy's TK Keyes is in the role players corner, below average in both: 4 explosive catches (402nd of 669 receivers and tight ends) and 288 receiving yards (204th). Troy's Jace Petty is in the role players corner, below average in both: 3 explosive catches (496th of 669 receivers and tight ends) and 174 receiving yards (424th). James Madison's Makai Jackson is in the role players corner, below average in both: 12 explosive catches (44th of 669 receivers and tight ends) and 540 receiving yards (40th). James Madison's Corey Scott is in the role players corner, below average in both: 11 explosive catches (60th of 669 receivers and tight ends) and 371 receiving yards (122nd).
PlayerExplosive catches (16+ yards)Receiving yards
TK Keyes, Troy4 (402nd)288 (204th)
Jace Petty, Troy3 (496th)174 (424th)
Makai Jackson, James Madison12 (44th)540 (40th)
Corey Scott, James Madison11 (60th)371 (122nd)

Who makes the plays on defense?

Who makes the plays on defense? Troy's top playmaker is Donnie Smith (2 sacks), 535th of 1571 FBS defenders in sacks plus takeaways. James Madison's top playmaker is DJ Kelly (4 INTs), 47th of 1571 FBS defenders in sacks plus takeaways.DJ Kelly, James Madison4 INTsJT Hooten, James Madison2 sacks, 1 INTNakian Jackson, James Madison2 sacks, 1 fumble recoveryDonnie Smith, Troy2 sacksTy Clemons, Troy2 sacksBryce Steele, Troy1 fumble recovery
Troy's top playmaker is Donnie Smith (2 sacks), 535th of 1571 FBS defenders in sacks plus takeaways. James Madison's top playmaker is DJ Kelly (4 INTs), 47th of 1571 FBS defenders in sacks plus takeaways.
PlayerSacksINTsFumble recoveriesFBS rank
DJ Kelly, James Madison04047th
JT Hooten, James Madison210155th
Nakian Jackson, James Madison201156th
Donnie Smith, Troy200535th
Ty Clemons, Troy200536th
Bryce Steele, Troy0011395th

The scatter charts show the top 40 FBS players at the position by both stats combined, plus the players lit here. Dashed lines are the averages; up and right is better. Ranks are among every FBS player at the position with enough snaps. Takeaways are interceptions plus fumble recoveries. Games through Oct 24, 2026.

How do SP+, PRIME and Elo rate Troy and James Madison?

On a neutral field, SP+ has James Madison 20.8 points better (29th to 108th). PRIME also has James Madison ahead, by 13.0. Elo, which only sees results, also has James Madison ahead (14th to 105th).

TroyJames Madison
SP+ overall-9.9 (108th)10.9 (29th)
SP+ offense19.1 (112th)32.5 (33rd)
SP+ defense28.8 (91st)21.7 (37th)
SP+ special teams-0.2 (92nd)0.1 (54th)
PRIME net-11.6 (114th)1.4 (64th)
PRIME offense-4.75 (103rd)-0.25 (64th)
PRIME defense-5.05 (108th)0.86 (59th)
PRIME SOS-8.1 (125th)-6.5 (105th)
PRIME SOR-1.8 (115th)1.8 (22nd)
Elo1314 (105th)1817 (14th)

Opponent-adjusted power ratings. These drive the projection.

Who's better once you adjust for the schedule?

Troy's offense ranks 102nd in adjusted EPA per play, and the James Madison defense it faces ranks 61st in EPA per play allowed. James Madison's offense ranks 22nd against Troy's 106th-ranked defense. The matchup that decides it is James Madison's offense against Troy's defense. The biggest edge on the board is James Madison's passing game: 23rd in adjusted EPA per pass, against Troy's 92nd-ranked defense. That's a mismatch. Adjust for opponents and Troy's defense falls from 52nd to 106th in EPA per play allowed: a lot of that came against soft offenses.

TroyJames Madison
EPA per play (adjusted)+0.06 (102nd)+0.19 (22nd)
EPA per pass (adjusted)+0.12 (118th)+0.28 (23rd)
EPA per rush (adjusted)+0.06 (68th)+0.10 (39th)
Success rate (adjusted)39.7% (93rd)42.7% (58th)
Success rate, standard downs (adjusted)46.3% (76th)46.7% (70th)
Success rate, passing downs (adjusted)27.5% (121st)33.0% (21st)
Explosiveness (adjusted)0.95 (37th)0.93 (94th)
Line yards per carry (adjusted)2.96 (65th)3.07 (39th)
Open-field yards per carry (adjusted)1.17 (56th)1.37 (13th)
EPA per play allowed (adjusted)+0.16 (106th)+0.09 (61st)
EPA per pass allowed (adjusted)+0.23 (92nd)+0.17 (54th)
EPA per rush allowed (adjusted)+0.10 (99th)+0.01 (31st)
Success rate allowed (adjusted)45.8% (115th)41.9% (70th)
Explosiveness allowed (adjusted)0.92 (27th)0.89 (8th)
Line yards allowed per carry (adjusted)3.05 (98th)2.97 (71st)
Open-field yards allowed per carry (adjusted)1.16 (81st)0.96 (17th)

The same efficiency numbers, adjusted for the offenses and defenses each team has faced (CollegeFootballData.com). A good number against a soft schedule shrinks; one against a hard schedule grows.

Who's more efficient, Troy or James Madison?

Troy is better running (56th in EPA per rush) than throwing (124th). James Madison's run defense ranks 20th, so the defense has the better of it. James Madison is about as good throwing (31st in EPA per pass) as running (35th).

TroyJames Madison
EPA per play+0.07 (100th)+0.24 (25th)
EPA per pass+0.01 (124th)+0.36 (31st)
EPA per rush+0.13 (56th)+0.17 (35th)
EPA per 3rd-down play+0.18 (125th)+0.43 (81st)
EPA per play allowed+0.06 (52nd)+0.02 (32nd)
EPA per pass allowed+0.10 (43rd)+0.12 (50th)
EPA per rush allowed+0.08 (76th)−0.06 (20th)
EPA per 3rd-down play allowed+0.30 (41st)+0.45 (86th)

Expected points added per play, from CollegeFootballData.com. EPA measures how much each play changes the points a team can expect from the drive. Zero is break-even; +0.20 is very good. Not adjusted for opponents.

Who scores more, Troy or James Madison?

Troy is outscored by 2.0 a game, and James Madison by 23.2. Troy's offense ranks 105th in scoring, and the James Madison defense it faces ranks 25th in points allowed. James Madison's offense ranks 5th against Troy's 76th-ranked defense. The matchup that decides it is James Madison's offense against Troy's defense.

TroyJames Madison
Points scored22.9 (105th)41.4 (5th)
Points allowed24.9 (76th)18.2 (25th)

Per game, FBS opponents only.

Which offense has the edge?

Troy has no clear edge here. Its best is yards per carry, 40th, against a defense ranked 38th in yards per carry allowed. James Madison's best matchup is its run game: its offense ranks 24th in yards per carry, and Troy's defense ranks 56th in yards per carry allowed.

TroyJames Madison
Pass yards / game179.7 (118th)249.9 (46th)
Rush yards / game211.7 (23rd)205.4 (27th)
Yards per play5.98 (85th)6.65 (36th)
Yards per carry5.53 (40th)5.89 (24th)
Yards per attempt7.19 (87th)7.66 (68th)
Completion %62.9% (71st)60.5% (84th)
Success rate41.9% (87th)45.4% (51st)
Explosive play rate10.5% (111th)14.2% (28th)
3rd down conversion37.0% (89th)35.6% (99th)
Sack rate (taken)7.9% (108th)3.0% (17th)
INT rate (thrown)2.9% (93rd)0.8% (12th)
SUPLEX54.4% (83rd)57.1% (62nd)

Per game and per play, from play-by-play.

Which defense has the edge?

Troy's defense is best placed to get off the field on third down: it ranks 17th in 3rd down conversions allowed, and James Madison's offense is bottom-40 in 3rd down conversion rate (99th). That's a mismatch. James Madison's defense is best placed to get home: it ranks 35th in sack rate, and Troy's offense is bottom-40 at avoiding sacks (108th). That's a mismatch.

TroyJames Madison
Pass yards allowed / game208.7 (66th)216.6 (78th)
Rush yards allowed / game133.3 (44th)119.8 (27th)
Yards per play allowed5.33 (41st)5.54 (55th)
Yards per carry allowed4.62 (56th)4.30 (38th)
Yards per attempt allowed6.16 (30th)7.13 (73rd)
Success rate allowed38.5% (48th)37.9% (40th)
Explosive plays allowed10.2% (48th)10.3% (52nd)
3rd downs allowed30.3% (17th)36.4% (50th)
Sack rate (generated)4.0% (118th)7.6% (35th)
INT rate (generated)1.7% (100th)2.9% (55th)
SUPLEX allowed53.2% (63rd)48.5% (31st)

What opponents managed against them.

Who wins the turnover battle?

James Madison is +0.8 in turnover margin a game and Troy is −0.1. At about five points a turnover, that's roughly a 4-point edge for James Madison. Turnover margin rarely holds from one month to the next, so don't count on it.

TroyJames Madison
Interceptions thrown / game0.71 (59th)0.25 (11th)
Fumbles lost / game0.57 (76th)0.50 (69th)
Giveaways / game1.29 (71st)0.75 (21st)
Interceptions / game0.57 (84th)0.88 (38th)
Fumbles recovered / game0.57 (49th)0.63 (40th)
Takeaways / game1.14 (66th)1.50 (36th)
Turnover margin / game-0.1 (76th)+0.8 (16th)

Per game, from play-by-play.

Which team has more talent?

Troy has the more talented roster (96th in the 247Sports talent composite; James Madison is 101st). But James Madison plays further above its talent: +15.6 points of SP+ beyond what its roster predicts, to Troy's −5.7.

TroyJames Madison
Talent composite596.2 (96th)588.3 (101st)
Blue-chip ratio4.2% (98th)6.6% (87th)
Players on roster104 (112th)109 (82nd)
Rated by 247Sports71 (93rd)61 (118th)
5-star players0 (37th)0 (37th)
4-star players3 (94th)4 (88th)
3-star players64 (56th)53 (99th)
Below 3-star4 (38th)4 (38th)
2026 transfers in15 (114th)41 (11th)
Transfer share21.1% (102nd)67.2% (7th)
SP+ vs. talent-5.7 (105th)+15.6 (7th)
Returning production35.3% (79th)8.0% (122nd)
Returning passing production102.8% (7th)9.3% (84th)
Returning rushing production135.7% (7th)6.6% (106th)
Returning receiving production11.6% (121st)8.6% (128th)
2026 recruiting class (national rank)76 (76th)80 (80th)
Recruiting rank, last four classes85.2 (79th)111.2 (114th)

247Sports team talent composite and 2026 transfer portal class. Star counts cover only the players 247Sports rates, not walk-ons, so they add up to less than the full roster. Ranks are out of all 138 FBS teams.

Where did each team's wins come from?

Troy is −0.5 wins against a .500 team; the biggest piece is schedule (+1.6). James Madison is +3.0 wins against a .500 team; the biggest piece is coaching (+2.1). Troy's record is 1.0 wins worse than its play on bad luck, so it's better than the record says.

TroyJames Madison
BAWA (total)-0.5 (89th)+3.0 (4th)
Schedule BAWA+1.6 (17th)+1.7 (12th)
Roster BAWA-0.3 (92nd)-0.8 (118th)
Coach BAWA-0.8 (101st)+2.1 (6th)
Luck BAWA-1.0 (119th)-0.1 (72nd)

Big Al Wins Added: where the wins came from. Every team starts as a .500 team. Then each win (or loss) goes to the schedule, the roster, the coaching or luck, and the four add up to the real record. Wins above or below a .500 team.

Troy at James Madison: questions people ask

Who will win Troy at James Madison?

Big Al picks James Madison, 93% to win. All three ratings favor the same team. James Madison's best matchup is its pass protection, 17th in sacks allowed per dropback, against Troy's pass rush at 118th.

When and where is Troy at James Madison?

Thu, Oct 29, 7:30 PM ET at Bridgeforth Stadium, on ESPN2.

What's the line for Troy at James Madison?

DraftKings has James Madison −21, total 49.5. Big Al picks winners, not bets.

What's the Troy–James Madison series record?

James Madison leads 2–0. Last meeting: James Madison won 31–14 in 2025.

Who are the quarterbacks in Troy at James Madison?

Troy's is Will Crowder (1,174 passing yards this season); James Madison's is Camden Coleman (1,574 passing yards this season).

More on this game

Numbers through the games of Oct 24, 2026. SP+ as of Oct 27, 2026. Updated every week.

Troy and James Madison: team pages with every stat and national rank. Compare any two teams.